Will There Be Grunting at the U.S. Open?
It seems that in the tennis world this year, all the talk is about grunting. It seems to be getting out of hand, according to those closely connected with the sport.
We’re talking, of course, about the loud grunt a player makes right as he or she is swinging the racket. And it’s especially become annoying for some with female players.
Want to know how widespread the problem has gotten? It’s even overflowed into kids’ tennis. AP reports that one nine year old girl in Sunbury, Australia, was banned from playing at a local club because of her loud grunts.
The girl is Lauryn Edwards, and the club banned her from playing tennis following an opposing player’s complaint. The Mt. Carmel Tennis club then told Lauryn’s flabbergasted parents. The father, Duncan Edwards, said the ban is “pathetic” and has made his own complaint to Tennis Australia and Tennis Victoria.
It’s no surprise to those familiar with tennis that Lauryn’s favorite player and idol is the notorious grunter, Russian player Maria Sharapova. However, Lauryn’s father says his daughter’s grunt is not at Sharapova’s level and that the situation is way overblown.
On the adult level, in advance of the U.S. Open, tennis legend Chris Evert has come out opposed to today’s loud grunting. She said she noticed that the grunting gets louder when the player hits what they perceive as a winning stroke, and that this smacks of poor sportsmanship. Evert says the loud grunts are distracting, and she feels they’re getting louder and louder with the younger generation of players.
So who are the sports loudest grunters among female tennis players The Tennis Federation rates them as following (Keep in mind that a lion’s roar is 110 decibels):
Maria Sharapova 101 decibels
Monica Seles 93.2 decibels
Serena Williams 88.9 decibels
Lindsay Davenport 88 decibels
Venus Williams 85 decibels
Victoria Azarenka 83.5 decibels
Elena Bovina 81 decibels
Anna Kournikova 78.5 decibels
Kim Clijsters 75 decibels
Elena Dementieva 73 decibels
As the current rules stand within the International Tennis Federation’s conduct code, an umpire can award a point to the opposing player if he feels that the player has hindered her in any intentional way. This would presumably mean by unnecessary grunting as well. In addition, there is a new proposal which, if passed, will ban outright the emitting of an excessive amount of noise during a game, with the grunter facing the possibility of a game or match forfeiture.
On the other side of the issue, in an interview with NPR, women’s tennis coach Luke Jensen of Syracuse University says there’s value to grunting. He says some players get so tied up with their emotions that grunting helps them release those emotions.
So will the grunting at the U.S. Open reflect the same kind of grunting that has been seen at Wimbledon. Perhaps. But then, Americans probably go in for that kind of thing more so than their counterparts over in the UK.